PHP 与继承和 LSB 的问题


PHP issue with inheritance and LSB

我遇到了以下问题:

<?php
/**
 * Mother class defining static methods/attribute
 */
class A
{
    public static $_greetings = 'Nothing';
    public static function hi()
        {
            $c = get_called_class();
            echo $c.' says '.$c::$_greetings.PHP_EOL;
        }
    public static function set($classname)
        {
            $c = get_called_class();
            $g = $classname::$_greetings;
            echo 'Setting '.$c.'::_greetings to '.$g.PHP_EOL;
            $c::$_greetings = $g;
        }
}
/**
 * Children using inherited static method
 */
class C1 extends A
{
    public function say() { self::hi(); }
}
class C2 extends A
{
    public function say() { self::hi(); }
}
/**
 * Data containers
 */
class D1
{
    public static $_greetings = 'Hello World!';
}
class D2
{
    public static $_greetings = 'Ola Chica!';
}
// ------------------------------------------------------------------------
/**
 * The great misunderstanding...
 */
C1::set( 'D1' );
C2::set( 'D2' );
$c1 = new C1();
$c2 = new C2();
$c1->say();
$c2->say();
echo C1::$_greetings.PHP_EOL;
echo C2::$_greetings.PHP_EOL;

简而言之,A定义了打印静态消息$_greetings的方法。此消息将使用A::set( classname )设置,该也接受包含静态参数$_greetings的类的名称的输入。然后是两个孩子,定义自己的方法say()使用继承的静态hi()打招呼。我希望输出是:

Setting C1::_greetings to Hello World!
Setting C2::_greetings to Ola Chica!
C1 says Hello World!
C2 says Ola Chica!
Hello World!
Ola Chica!

但相反,我得到:

Setting C1::_greetings to Hello World!
Setting C2::_greetings to Ola Chica!
C1 says Ola Chica!
C2 says Ola Chica!
Ola Chica!
Ola Chica!

我想知道为什么...!?提前非常感谢那些花时间了解问题的人:)

我可以在这里找到答案,即使这个问题的措辞方式不同:PHP 5.3:在父类中定义属性时,后期静态绑定不适用于属性,而在子类中缺少属性

在我的小例子中,问题来自这样一个事实,显然,除非另有说明(见下文如何(,静态变量的存储对于类的"家庭"(即,对于母类和所有子类(是相同的。为了确保每个类都有自己的存储,您只需要在子类中重新声明相同的静态变量,如下所示:

/**
 * Children using inherited static method
 */
class C1 extends A
{
    public static $_greetings;
    public function say() { self::hi(); }
}
class C2 extends A
{
    public static $_greetings;
    public function say() { self::hi(); }
}

将其放回前面的示例,输出完全符合预期:

Setting C1::_greetings to Hello World!
Setting C2::_greetings to Ola Chica!
C1 says Hello World!
C2 says Ola Chica!
Hello World!
Ola Chica!